Who Is Most Likely a Pumpkin Pie? Free Printable Game

Have you ever met someone who always saves room for dessert or sneaks a midnight treat from the fridge? I have a feeling we all know someone who fits the description!

That’s what makes Who’s Most Likely such a fun little game to play with family and friends.

It’s full of playful prompts that might reveal a few unexpected things about the people you know best.

This game is also a handy little filler between courses or something to play while everyone waits for the Thanksgiving feast to be ready. It works for all ages kids, parents and grandparents, so everyone can join in. You can even bring it out for your next family game night.

This post contains affiliate links please see the full disclosure policy.

About the Printable – Who Is Most Likely a Pumpkin Pie

I’ve put together two versions of this free game, so you can choose your favorite or print both and keep the fun going.

The first is Who’s Most Likely to Be a Pumpkin Pie? with dessert-inspired prompts about pumpkin pie, baking, and Thanksgiving favorites.

The second is Who’s Most Likely to Be a Turkey? with silly Thanksgiving-themed prompts about holiday traditions, things you’re wearing, and little quirks that might earn you some points.

Both versions are easy to play and work well for getting conversations started around the table as well as keeping everyone entertained.

This Thanksgiving Game Is Great For

• Classroom fun.

• Family dinners.

• Fall parties and events.

• Thanksgiving morning

• Family game nights

You’ll find this free printable game at the end of this post, along with more Thanksgiving games

How to Play Who’s most likely to be a pumpkin pie

This game is as easy as they come, with no unnecessary rules or anything, you can literally play it anywhere. Here’s how to play:

Get everyone a game sheet. Print a copy of the free printable for each player so everyone can join in.

Read the prompts and collect points. Go through the statements on the sheet and earn the points whenever they apply to you. Keep an eye on the point values beside each one!

Tally up your score. Once everyone has gone through the sheet, add up the points you’ve earned.

Crown your winner! The player with the highest score wins the title of Pumpkin Pie!

And that’s your game! All you need is the printed game sheet and a group ready for some Thanksgiving laughs.

Who’s most likely a Pumpkin Pie Prompts

Here is a sneak-peak on the fun prompts contained in free Thanksgiving printable game who’s most likely a Pumpkin Pie.

5 points if you can bake a pumpkin pie without a recipe

• 1 point if your love dessert for breakfast

• 2 points for every letter of P U M P K I N in your name

• 2 points if you prefer the crust to the pie filling.

• 5 points if you can name 3 spices used in pumpkin pie

• 2 points if you’ve ever helped make a dessert.

• 2 points if you can name three desserts made with pumpkin.

Who’s most likely a Turkey Prompts

Here is a sneak-peak on the fun prompts contained in free Thanksgiving printable game who’s most likely a Turkey Pumpkin Pie.

• 3 Points for 3 Words That Rhyme With Gobble

• 1 point if You Have Brown Eyes

• 3 points if you have ever participated in a Turkey Trot

• 1 point if you Have A Text With The Word “Thanksgiving”

• 2 points If You Have Broken A Wishbone

• 2 points if your birthday is in November

• 3 points if you are wearing polka dots

How To Get Your Most Likely To Games

Download the File: Fill out the form at bottom of this post get your free games.

Check your email: Your free printable will be sent to your email within a few minutes after you sign up.

Check your Spam: if you don’t see it in your inbox, check your Spam, Junk, or Promotions folder. Still can’t find it? Try searching your inbox for “Oh Well Yes”.

Add email: Be sure to add my email address to your contacts so you don’t miss future free printables and seasonal goodies!

Use cardstock paper if you want them to reuse these printables.

Make sure your printer is set to “Fit to Page”. I really think HP Home Printer does this job beautifully.

Slip each one into a sheet protector or use a laminator for extra durability.

More Thanksgiving Games and Activities

80 Fact or Fiction Thanksgiving Trivia: Challenge your family and friends and see who can separate Thanksgiving facts from myths!

Thanksgiving Guess the Price: A fun party game where everyone tries to guess the prices of Thanksgiving feast staples!

Thanksgiving Worst Advice Ever: Play this hilarious game of Thanksgiving bad advice for tacking equally horrible situations!

Thanksgiving Would you Rather: 90 hilarious and silly “Would You Rather” questions the whole family will love answering!

Thanksgiving Family-friendly Movies: Keep the holiday spirit going with these cozy movies to watch with the whole crew.

I hope you liked this game idea; you can get these free games along with a host of other free Thanksgiving printables by signing up the form below.